I agree with Etienne, Mencken means that he only award people who work very hard and put their heart in to what they are doing, and the cuases that led to do the things they are doing.
I believe he is saying that after seeing all of the ugly places in all of the cities he has traveled to, and after doing all of his research, that he has found the worst of the worst in the villages he is seeing while traveling on the pennsylvania Railroad. He states that he has seen all of the unlovely towns of the world and they are all found in America. After writing all of the places he has been to that have been ugly or horrible he qoutes "But nowhere on this earth, at home or abroad, have I seen anthing to compare to the villages that huddle along the line of the Pennsylvania from the Pittsburgh yards to Greensburg." Therfore he is saying he awards this championship of the ugliest and worst place ever to these villages.
In my opinion this quote means that after hard work and praying without ceasing he has come to the decision that the United States should get to award of championship for " the most unlovely towns of the world." After searching various towns, cities and countries he has come to the conclusion to give the United States the award. The tone of this article is sarcasm/anger. As If he is upset with the different styles of unlovely homes and towns he has seen in all of his travel.
We have to remember that H.L. Mencken was a misanthrope (a person who dislikes humankind and avoids human society) and a polemicist (a strong verbal or written attack on someone or something), so he did not like people and had no problem talking about and showing it. That being said, the negativity of this essay reinforces his personality.
The author addresses this sentence to whole American nation as a leader in tendency to ugliness. It is a fact that he earned through researching entire world and concluded that money were not matter in that case. More specifically, peasant villages in Europe look more fancy than American industrial cities. It means that Americans not attempt to beauty and prefer gray reality in daily life.
In this very critical article,the writer simply means that,in his eyes Pennsylvania is one of the worst places he has seen and that it should not be that way, as he says "Here was the very heart of industrial America". It almost feels like he has great hatred for the place by the way he goes about describing it and trying to make us the readers visualize his exaggerations.He makes mention of other cities in the U.S.A and briefly criticizes them.As the article said "He rarely had much good to say about anybody or anything" but I guess he was really not happy with what he had see there in Pittsburgh
Mencken only saw the ugliness in the world. It was a fact that he did not believe in the Christian God, because he figured if God existed there would not no ugliness in the world. So he finds it most obvious in America that the world is a cultural wasteland. He is implying a sarcastic tone and does not why they continue.
I will say that the ugly means the lies because it's stated at the last paragraph"Out of the melting pot emerges a race which hates beauty as it hates truth." Therefore, i think that the author saying this as a comparison. However, the ugly means the laws in my understanding.
I do not have your email, please email me privately, this is a strange place to post also. we went over the essays we read and did some in class writing. You need to make sure you are up to date on all assignments. Everything you need is posted here already.
In this line Mencken mean he can only award a person by how hard he work, about the positive thing he did to get his work done ...
ReplyDeleteI agree with Etienne, Mencken means that he only award people who work very hard and put their heart in to what they are doing, and the cuases that led to do the things they are doing.
ReplyDeleteRead it over again, look at the context of the entire piece
ReplyDeleteI believe he is saying that after seeing all of the ugly places in all of the cities he has traveled to, and after doing all of his research, that he has found the worst of the worst in the villages he is seeing while traveling on the pennsylvania Railroad. He states that he has seen all of the unlovely towns of the world and they are all found in America. After writing all of the places he has been to that have been ugly or horrible he qoutes "But nowhere on this earth, at home or abroad, have I seen anthing to compare to the villages that huddle along the line of the Pennsylvania from the Pittsburgh yards to Greensburg." Therfore he is saying he awards this championship of the ugliest and worst place ever to these villages.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion this quote means that after hard work and praying without ceasing he has come to the decision that the United States should get to award of championship for " the most unlovely towns of the world." After searching various towns, cities and countries he has come to the conclusion to give the United States the award. The tone of this article is sarcasm/anger. As If he is upset with the different styles of unlovely homes and towns he has seen in all of his travel.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWe have to remember that H.L. Mencken was a misanthrope (a person who dislikes humankind and avoids human society) and a polemicist (a strong verbal or written attack on someone or something), so he did not like people and had no problem talking about and showing it. That being said, the negativity of this essay reinforces his personality.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe author addresses this sentence to whole American nation as a leader in tendency to ugliness. It is a fact that he earned through researching entire world and concluded that money were not matter in that case. More specifically, peasant villages in Europe look more fancy than American industrial cities. It means that Americans not attempt to beauty and prefer gray reality in daily life.
ReplyDeleteIn this very critical article,the writer simply means that,in his eyes Pennsylvania is one of the worst places he has seen and that it should not be that way, as he says "Here was the very heart of industrial America". It almost feels like he has great hatred for the place by the way he goes about describing it and trying to make us the readers visualize his exaggerations.He makes mention of other cities in the U.S.A and briefly criticizes them.As the article said "He rarely had much good to say about anybody or anything" but I guess he was really not happy with what he had see there in Pittsburgh
ReplyDeleteMencken only saw the ugliness in the world. It was a fact that he did not believe in the Christian God, because he figured if God existed there would not no ugliness in the world. So he finds it most obvious in America that the world is a cultural wasteland. He is implying a sarcastic tone and does not why they continue.
ReplyDeleteI will say that the ugly means the lies because it's stated at the last paragraph"Out of the melting pot emerges a race which hates beauty as it hates truth." Therefore, i think that the author saying this as a comparison. However, the ugly means the laws in my understanding.
ReplyDeletehi Mr Resnick can you please email me what we did in class on Saturday? i was absent
ReplyDeleteI do not have your email, please email me privately, this is a strange place to post also. we went over the essays we read and did some in class writing. You need to make sure you are up to date on all assignments. Everything you need is posted here already.
ReplyDelete